Junior Great Books: This is What Teaching Reading Should Look Like0 comments
Those of you who have been following this blog may remember that I have been teaching a group of about 17 bright, young students (1st and 2nd graders) in an Enrichment group 5 days a week for 45 minutes. This group is proficient/advanced in reading and tested out of our scripted Corrective Reading program that the rest of the students in their grade participate in. When I was assigned this group I was given no materials, no curriculum and no guidance as to what I was supposed to be teaching these bright minds.
It was kind of exciting. Over the last few months we have created a podcast, written Storybird stories and are almost finished with a VoiceThread. Since no one was telling me what to teach, and it was an Enrichment group, I figured, "What could be more enriching than creating authentic assignments for them?" Then, a few weeks ago I got a message from my principal telling me that the following day (nothing like last minute!) I would be attending a training on a new program for my Enrichment group. "Great. Now they're giving me a scripted program," I thought. I hopped on the subway the next morning to William Penn High School (at least it was easy to get to) to attend the training. I'm sure you're all familiar with the feeling I had as I walked in the room and found a seat. "Let's just get this over with. At least I have my laptop, so I can get some things done." Boy was I wrong. Turns out, the program, Junior Great Books was exactly the opposite of what I expected. I was so engaged and busy I didn't have time to even look at my laptop, which sat closed in front of me. The presenter/trainer engaged us in a 45 minute Shared Inquiry discussion about--no joke--Jack and the Beanstalk. Junior Great Books, part of the Great Books Foundation's reading program, provides kids with real, un-watered down literature. It provides them a chance to read the story numerous times, each time delving deeper into the story. It also provides them with a chance to discuss the book focused around an Inquiry question created by the teacher. (Ours was "Why was Jack not content after his second time up the beanstalk?") During the discussion, the teacher can only ask questions. There is no "good idea, Jimmy," or "Good point, Susan." It's a true Socratic discussion with the teacher as the discussion leader. There are 5 Sessions per week/per story:
Here is a sample Shared Inquiry discussion: (it's with 7th graders, but the model is the same for my age group as well)Harrison Bergeron Discussion from The Great Books Foundation on Vimeo. I introduced our first story, The Happy Lion, to my students on Tuesday. It is definitely a challenging read for my 1st graders, so I gave the option for all students to either read along in their books or listen with their book closed like a bedtime story. One of my 1st graders curled up in his chair to listen! After reviewing some new vocabulary (like Bonjour and Au revoir), we got started. I told them that this was the first time we were hearing the story, so I would not be asking them questions or answering questions; we would just read it to enjoy the story. I told them that I would take questions at the end. (If you want to hear the story, you can listen to me read it here) After a nice, quiet, yet engaged read aloud I asked if there were any questions. A couple of questions were about vocabulary words like hubbub and swished. Then the most amazing thing happened. My students, unprompted, asked inquiry questions. First came: "Why did the people all say, 'Hi' to the lion, but when the lion said, 'Hi,' they all ran away?" Then: "Why does the lion say 'so this is what people must act like when they're not at the zoo?'" I couldn't believe how sophisticated these questions were. These are 1st and 2nd graders! We put the questions up on the board to keep them in mind for our later readings of the story. All I could think was: "So THIS is what teaching reading should look like!" I'm saddened that only my group of students gets to experience this wonderful program that will definitely pique their interest in reading, engage them with wonderful stories and build their critical thinking and discussing skills. Their peers are stuck reciting phonics and tracking words. What will happen, I wonder, to those students' love of reading and ability to think deeply about what they are reading? A New Model for School Reform: Could it Work?0 comments
Recently, with all of this change coming to Philadelphia schools, in conversation with fellow educators at the Educon conference and some engaging conversation on Twitter and Google Buzz I've been thinking about what a good model of school reform would look like.
Many of my colleagues and I agree that expanding the Charter School model would not help, but rather hurt our local school system here in Philadelphia. Charter Schools are like a 'brain drain' from the neighborhood schools. They also have the ability to sift out families and students who don't 'buy in' to their philosophy or structure. Which leaves the hardest to teach, most struggling students and families left in the neighborhood schools, which often don't have the resources to serve such a population. The new Renaissance School movement in Philadelphia and elsewhere (sometimes by a different name) through which chronically failing schools are closed and reopened under new (sometimes private) management will not fix the problem of failing schools. It is, as they say, a "Band-Aid" solution. The model chosen to take over the school may completely turn the school around, but if it is a Charter model, what happens in the likely occasion that many families are disengaged with their child's education? Will they be forced out? Where will they go? Back to the neighborhood school. What I don't think has been part of the discussion is the structure of the neighborhood school that sets it up to fail. In Philadelphia, you are required to attend the school that is assigned to your geographic location. In general, poor neighborhoods are plagued with the typical issues that poverty brings about: broken family units, joblessness, poor health, low levels of literacy and education, violence, drugs as well as parents who work more than one job to support their family. When a school serves such a community, it has much greater hurdles to surpass than the neighborhood school in a 'working class' or affluent neighborhood. I understand I am talking completely in stereotypes and it may be offensive to some of you reading this, but I am speaking from experience. When I am in a room with Philadelphia teachers from all over the city, I can predict what someone's daily experience is like just from the part of the city they teach in. It is a well known fact that the neighborhood you teach in has a direct affect on how involved your parents will be in their child's education, how many of your students will be suffering from abuse, PTSD, come from foster homes or require special attention due to anger issues or severe learning gaps. Charter schools break this model by pulling from different parts of the city. A Charter school taking over a failing school cannot do this due to a stipulation in their takeover contract that they must take over the school and all of its current students according to school boundaries. I am very curious to see how this stipulation will affect the effectiveness of the model. I believe that it's this diversity of student body that helps these kinds of schools succeed (along with their autonomy in school management). When a school pulls from all over the city, its students are exposed to children who don't look like them, who have different views of the world or even children who come from across the city but share a similar life experience. In addition, there is less stress on the school's resources when the student body is more diverse. I've been pondering all this and remembered reading about districts who still bus their students in accordance with Brown vs. Board of Education to desegregate their schools. The model I read about gave every student entering Kindergarten a chance to choose the school they attended through a lottery system. Each student provided their top 5 choices of schools to attend, which could include the school closest to their house. The assignments were given based on available openings and lottery. The district provided busing for all students, much like how Charters provide busing to their students who come from other parts of the city. This model would have to be different from the forced busing of the past with the purpose of keeping schools racially balanced. In the model I am envisioning, students can put the school right down the street as their #1 choice, and students would be allowed entry into the school of their choice based on available openings with no preference for race, academic achievement or socioeconomic status. Why do I like this model?
Could this ever work in Philadelphia? It would require a huge shift in policy--the end of the boundary system, parent outreach to explain the new system (which wouldn't be much different from the current system in place that helps parents choose a Charter school for their child), and a plan for how to allocate services to schools, which could be based on the current model that determines the number of Special Education teachers, counselors and support staff. Even the student ID numbers wouldn't have to change, or school location numbers. Ok, ok, I'll step off my cloud now and come back to Earth. If you have experienced busing or have an opinion about it, I would love to hear it. Please leave a comment! For more on the busing debate: American Law and Legal Library E-notes.com-Everyday Law Encyclopedia StateMaster.com-Forced Busing Inauguration, Racism and Segregation <---one of my previous posts on the topic I Love This Job: A Follow Up0 comments
A couple days ago I wrote about a student in my class who was struggling with completing work in my class. After a breakthrough moment in which I expressed to him the importance of taking risks and not fearing challenges, I wondered if this moment would have lasting effects. Yesterday, I had him again, and while he still had a lot of "Ms. Hertz I _____" moments asking for help and guidance, I could sense a change.
Sadly, he still struggled to complete the drawing, and I felt crushed. As I dropped the class off for lunch, M___ came up to me and asked me if he could come back to the classroom to work on his drawing. I looked at him, and seeing his pleading eyes, I couldn't say "no." We walked back to the lab. I asked him why he didn't finish it during class. He replied, "They were too loud." (note: the class was no louder than usual while working on a project) I realized that he was sensitive to noise while he worked. In the relative silence of the empty lab, I sat at my desk while he worked on his drawing. Every once in a while he would ask me how to do something, and I would tell him which tool might meet his needs. I didn't get up once or need to model. The verbal directions I gave were enough. As he worked, I could tell that he was constantly seeking approval. At one point he even asked me whether his drawing was "right." I told him that his drawing was HIS. The only way that he could be 'wrong' was if the assignment was to draw a pig and he drew a boat. I told him that when I was a child I had an art teacher who told me that I was the 'boss' of my art and that no one could tell me how to draw. I also explained that not all teachers were like that; that some teachers might say his drawings were wrong, but not to worry about it. He seemed satisfied. Here is the final drawing: Using Drop.io in the Classroom0 comments
My 4-6th graders have been working Persuasive Essays for the last month. (While that seems like a long time, it is really only 4-5 class periods.) I decided to have them hand in their work using a drop.io dropbox rather than my server dropbox so I can grade their work from home.
While playing around with the drop.io settings and functions, I noticed a 'comment' feature. "How cool!" I thought. Not only could they read each others' essays, but they could leave feedback as well! I created a guest password and linked it to their assignment page. They logged in and then the fun began. It was so exciting to see them taking the time to read each other's essays. While the comments were not exactly what I wanted (some were more about say "what's up" or "you go girl" than actual feedback--totally my own fault because we didn't spend a lot of time going over giving useful feedback) it was fun and engaging for them and they were excited to know that their work was being read by their classmates. There were a few teachable moments when a student posted a "so and so likes you" comment to a boy's essay and when another student left a few rude comments signing someone else's name. It gave me a chance to remind them that once you put your words and thoughts up on the Internet, they are there forever and you can't take them back. It also gave me a chance to discuss netiquette and real life situations that occur when using social media. I kept having to remind myself that nothing is perfect the first time you try it. This was a great activity and a successful one with a few hiccups, and it is a great jumping off point for the collaborative work I am planning for the Spring. Every day I see proof of the power of social media to motivate students to engage with content. There is no other kind of tool that would allow for students to view each others' work so quickly and leave feedback so easily. Also, knowing that others are going to read your work, especially one's peers, often motivates students to take more time and be more careful in how they write and what they write. Now my question: am I going to get in trouble now? The District is so fearful of these kinds of tools and activities. Oh Yeah, This is Why I Love this Job0 comments
I just had to share a smile in all of the doom and gloom I've been sharing recently.
Background: One of my students has spent the last few weeks saying, "I don't know _____" ...fill in the blank with whatever assignment we're supposed to be working on. It got to the point where I was feeling hopeless. He would sit for 45 minutes repeating this over and over no matter what kinds of supports, ideas and explanations I tried. Finally, last week, I pulled him aside and had a short conference with him. I can't remember exactly what we talked about, but I know I was exasperated. Back to today: We are making avatars for our VoiceThread project. Here it came: "Ms. Hertz, I need help. I don't know how to make a face." "OK, M___, I'm coming." I showed him the circle tool and modeled it for him, then deleted what I did and let him play around. About 10 minutes later, he came up with this: Next he began working on his Three Little Pigs illustration. He was drawing the wolf, a brick house and the pig. He pulled me over. "Ms. Hertz, are wolves furry?" "Yes," I replied. He pointed to his drawing. He had used the chalk tool to blend the edges of his lines to make his wolf look furry. I could barely hide my joy. (OK, I didn't hide it at all.) "See," I said, "you can't know how to do something unless you try it first!" Later that day, his class came for Computers (I teach him every day for an Enrichment period in the morning). For weeks we had been struggling with his Storybird story. "Ms. Hertz, I don't know what to write. Ms. Hertz, I need help. Ms Hertz, I can't find that picture." In 2 weeks he hadn't even completed a cover yet. You get the idea. Today, he sat down, chose a cover picture, wrote a title and completed his first page. I wanted to hug him. (The only reason I didn't is because he probably would have been embarrassed or confused, I know him well enough at this point!) When he was done, he asked, "Can I work on my drawing?" Sadly, we were out of time, but it was thrilling to see him suddenly not afraid to take risks and motivated to try something that was a challenge. These small victories and celebrations mean so much to me. Today was a reminder why I could never see myself doing anything else.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Creative Commons LicensePhilly Teacher by Mary Beth Hertz is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. Save Trees: Don't print me!Subscribe via emailAbout Me
Labels
reflection
(29)
teaching
(26)
educational technology
(20)
technology
(16)
reform
(14)
"Social Media"
(9)
ISTE
(8)
PLN
(8)
twitter
(7)
#edchat
(6)
leadership
(6)
School District of Philadelpia
(5)
#iste10
(4)
Educon
(4)
SDP
(4)
blogging
(4)
social networking
(4)
"edcamp philly" conference
(3)
Diigo
(3)
book review
(3)
"#140 characters conference
(2)
"Leadership Day 2010"
(2)
"Renaissance Schools"
(2)
EduBloggerCon
(2)
Internet Safety
(2)
Storybird
(2)
digital storytelling
(2)
education nation
(2)
edutopia
(2)
superman
(2)
" ISTE
(1)
edcamp
(1)
Leave me a Message
Powered by Blogger.
|





